• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

White Street Pizza - Best Homemade Pizza & Fresh Salads in Key West, FL

White Street Pizza in Key West is a true culinary gem, renowned for its light, chewy crusts and fresh, homemade ingredients. Guests rave about the handcrafted pizzas like the spinach artichoke white and classic sausage mushroom, praised as some of the best in town. The salads impress with perfect dressings and vibrant flavors, complementing the meal exquisitely. Highlight dishes like the flavorful meatballs and decadent tiramisu add depth to the menu. Friendly service and a cozy atmosphere round out the experience, making White Street Pizza a must-visit spot for anyone seeking authentic, lovingly prepared Italian fare in a welcoming setting.

White Street Pizza at a glance

  • Address 1110 White St, Key West, FL 33040, United States
  • Phone +1 305-735-4449
  • Restaurant type Restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

White Street Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Stacey Hardy
5

It’s delicious! Lovingly made pizzas have a terrific crust that is light and chewy. Salads are some of the very best in Key West, perfectly dressed and always excellent. Good wine selection. A gem in this town!

Mike Harder
5

Wow! I have been visiting regularly for 15 pkus years and this is by far the BEST pizza in Key West! All homemade, great ingredients. Excellent service. I got my order to go, even a custom printed pizza box! Very nice inside if you want to sit down and have a meal also! Do not pass this hidden gem up!

Diane Kohlhepp
5

We were a group of 6. We had salads, meatballs, Sausage pizza and plain pizza. Everything was delicious! The pizza was amazing! The best we have ever had in Key West! Our server was so very pleasant! Give it a try! You will be happy you did!

Melissa
5

We absolutely loved our dinner - the spinach artichoke white pizza was her favorite food of our whole trip! The cauliflower salad was also delicious. Also AC is perfect and staff is super friendly. We will definitely be back!

Robin Hattaway
5

We had to try a few things to give a proper review The meatballs are to die for ! Get your own order because you won’t want to share. Tiramisu also scrumptious ! We had the key lime pie & a sausage and mushroom pizza. The crust was thin, just the way I like it. 10 out of 10.

Katherine Bernardi
5

What a wonderful place with great food and amazing service! Happy hour is a must from 5pm-6pm offering half off appetizers, salads and wine! just got home from Italy a few weeks ago and felt like I never left. My mom and I decided to grab 4 appetizers to share while my fiancé went for the simple yet delicious pepperoni pizza (you just can’t go wrong) my favorite was the Marinated Beef Tips while my mom loved the Grilled Watermelon Salad . Definitely a new hidden gem!

Shawn Flaming
5

This is a great little spot off the beaten path. From the time you enter you get the feeling of cozy small family owned restaurant. We loved the ambiance with comfortable booths. Very good service from the two young gentleman working there. Gave us an idea of the menu and what some of their more popular items were. Also informed us of the Happy Hour specials which was 50% off wine and pizza. What a great deal. My wife ordered the Sauvignon blanc which was a perfect pairing with the food we got. We went with the mushroom pizza but I could recommend any of their pizza, I’m sure they won’t disappoint. The beef tips were good but my favorite was their Roasted Brussels & Cauliflower. We will definitely be going back there and looking forward to trying new items.

Location

  • White Street Pizza
    White Street Pizza
    1110 White St, Key West, FL 33040, United States Hotline: +1 305-735-4449

Nestled in the heart of Key West at 1110 White St, White Street Pizza is a culinary beacon for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. This unassuming gem has long been celebrated for its thoughtfully crafted menu that blends traditional Italian roots with fresh, local ingredients. From the moment you step inside, the inviting ambiance and attentive service set the stage for a memorable dining experience.

The pizzas here are truly exceptional. The crust strikes the perfect balance — light, chewy, and thin enough to let the toppings shine without overwhelming the senses. The spinach artichoke white pizza, a standout favorite, delivers layers of creamy, savory flavor that linger delightfully. Their sausage and mushroom pizza also commands attention with its well-seasoned toppings and crisp bite.

Beyond pizza, White Street Pizza offers some of the finest salads in Key West. The cauliflower salad, for instance, is vibrantly fresh, perfectly dressed, and a refreshing counterpart to the hearty pies. Their meatballs deserve special mention; rich, tender, and seasoned with care, they invite you to savor every bite — so much so that you'll want your own order.

Desserts like the tiramisu and key lime pie round out the meal with just the right touch of sweetness, delivering classic Italian and Floridian flair in each forkful. Complementing the food is a thoughtfully curated wine selection that elevates the flavors and rounds out the experience beautifully.

White Street Pizza's dedication to quality shines through in every aspect — from the homemade dough and fresh ingredients to the friendly, knowledgeable staff who make you feel right at home. Whether you choose to dine in their comfortable, air-conditioned space or take advantage of their custom printed pizza boxes to go, this is more than just a meal; it's a celebration of authentic, heartfelt pizza-making.

For anyone seeking the best pizza in Key West coupled with excellent service and an inviting atmosphere, White Street Pizza is not to be missed. After multiple visits and a generous sampling of their offerings, it’s clear why locals and visitors alike crown this spot as a culinary highlight of the island.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards